The 15 Best Hotels in Theater District NYC (Top Broadway Hotels)

If you are looking for the best hotels in the Theater District of NYC, you have come to the right place.

Throughout the Broadway Theater District, there are many hotels to choose from. However, this list will point out 15 of the very best hotels out there.

Whether you are planning to frequently visit the Broadway Theaters, head to Times Square, or just be centrally located in NYC, then picking one of these hotels will work well for you.

* Affiliate Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission if you make a purchase through the links provided, at no additional cost to you. Thanks for supporting the work I put into TripTins!

Best Hotels in the Theater District

To start, below are the 15 hotels that I will be talking more about throughout this overview. Feel free to click on the links to book and continue reading to learn more about each one.

1. Marriott Marquis
2. Casablanca Hotel
3. M Social Times Square
4. The Knickerbocker
5. Renaissance Times Square
6. CIVILIAN Hotel Times Square
7. AKA Times Square
8. CitizenM Hotel Times Square
9. Hard Rock Hotel
10. The Michelangelo
11. Sanctuary Hotel
12. Bryant Park Hotel
13. The Muse
14. Merrion Row Hotel
15. The Pearl

Learn More: since Times Square is in the Theater District, you will find much overlap between hotels. Feel free to take a look at the best hotels with a view of Times Square if that is of interest to you.

Where is the Broadway Theater District?

In general, the Broadway Theater District runs from 40^th Street up to 57^th Street, between 6^th Avenue and 8^th Avenue. The hotels you will find on this list will all be within this boundary (or very close to it).

You are guaranteed to be in walking distance to many Broadway Theaters, Times Square, and even places like Central Park.

NYC Tip! Broadway is both a street name in NYC that runs up & down nearly the entirety of Manhattan, and a nickname for the Theater District (the street runs through the Theater District too!). If you want to stay near the actual Broadway Theaters, be sure to choose a hotel around the district itself.

1) Marriott Marquis

The Marriott Marquis takes pride of place in the area, with one of the best possible locations in the Theater District. It also has a 360-degree revolving restaurant that provides unmatched views of the Manhattan skyline.

Due to its prime location, the Marriott Marquis is able to offer many rooms that share those spectacular views. Almost all guestrooms will look out onto Times Square, Broadway, or both.

In addition, the guestrooms at the Marquis are surprisingly spacious. This is doubly surprising when you consider the fact that real estate is at a premium here.

2) Casablanca Hotel

The Casablanca Hotel is a classy establishment that draws inspiration from the movie of the same name. The hotel has an elegant Mediterranean vibe that makes it relaxing despite its busy location. As hotels near Broadway in NYC go, it’s one of the best.

Rooms are spacious and luxuriously decorated. The plush bedding and furniture continue the Moroccan feel, with plenty of lavish silks and wicker chairs. If you’re looking to splash out, the suites offer some of the roomiest guestrooms you’re likely to find nearby.

3) M Social Times Square

The M Social is one of the best affordable hotels near Broadway. Even though you’ll be located right amid the bustle of the Square, the hotel itself is an island of calm. Add to this top-notch service and relatively large guest rooms, and it’s a great pick.

M Social is one of the few hotels that is almost on Broadway itself. With the right room, you can enjoy views of the famous theater-packed street. There is also a terrace attached to the hotel where you can relax and check out the action below.

4) The Knickerbocker

If you’re looking for one of the best hotels near Broadway in NYC, then The Knickerbocker is a strong option. It’s close to Bryant Park, making it great if you’d like to escape the crowds with a quiet stroll.

The Knickerbocker markets itself as “the first luxury hotel in Times Square”. It’s certainly hard to dispute part of that claim, as the hotel is very high class. 

Though the exterior retains its classic look, the interior has been fully renovated. The Knickerbocker’s 330 guestrooms are each individually furnished with top-of-the-line fabrics and furniture.

5) Renaissance Times Square

The Renaissance Times Square is an oasis of calm amid the crowds and lights. It’s without a doubt one of the most notable hotels in the area.

The hotel couldn’t be better placed for getting into the thick of the action. Yet despite its prime location, the interior of the hotel is peaceful. With high-quality soundproofing, you can rest assured of a good night’s sleep.

6) CIVILIAN Hotel Times Square

The CIVILIAN is one of the best boutique hotels near the Theater District – it’s just over the border in Hell’s Kitchen.

The CIVILIAN drapes itself in understated class. The owners drew extensively upon neighborhood talent when designing the hotel. This makes it one of the most authentically ‘local’ NYC hotels that you’ll come across. This grounded touch is felt throughout, from the artwork on the walls to the design of the guestrooms.

7) AKA Times Square

AKA Times Square is a property that offers furnished luxury apartments at the Crossroads of the World. For a city stay that combines a fantastic location with a relaxing environment, it’s hard to beat this hotel.

Found on West 44^th Street, it’s actually about half a block away from Times Square. This is a benefit more than anything, however. It keeps you away from the crowds and noise a little, while allowing you to quickly get around the Theater District. And while in the apartment itself, you won’t be able to hear a thing.

8) CitizenM New York Times Square

CitizenM is one of the better budget hotels near Broadway. And while ‘budget’ is relative when you’re in the world’s most recognizable square, it’s as cheap as you’ll find.

The hotel is just great for travelers who need only the basics while they explore the Theater District.

It’s one of the few hotels that sits very near to Broadway itself. It’s on W 50^th Street, mere steps away. If you’re looking to enjoy a show, then, it’s hard to find a better-located hotel.

9) Hard Rock Hotel NYC

The Hard Rock Hotel NYC is one of the most flavorful and characterful hotels in NYC. It’s also one of the best luxury hotels in the area, with easy access to the Theater District.

The Hard Rock Hotel oozes character from the moment you set foot inside. In the lobby you’ll find outfits and memorabilia taken from Beyoncé, Jay-Z and Alicia Keys. The latter two collaborated on ‘Empire State of Mind’ (a classic NYC nickname), and their influence is felt frequently.

10) The Michelangelo New York

The Michelangelo is easily one of the best boutique hotels in the Theater District. It brings a touch of Italian sophistication to Midtown, with neoclassical touches common.

The building dates from 1926, and was always intended to be a hotel. This made the Michelangelo’s interior redesigns minimal. One area in which they have distinguished it is in the Italian influence, however. This is particularly notable in the lobby, which overflows with floral displays and tinkling chandeliers.

11) Sanctuary Hotel New York

Sanctuary Hotel is one of the finest luxury hotels around. And, as its name suggests, it’s a fine sanctuary from the hectic NYC streets outside.

Sanctuary has a total of 115 guestrooms. Each of these is richly decorated and has lavish European linens and fabrics, making for a wonderfully comfortable experience. The commitment to an almost Zen-like Buddhist calm in the hotel makes it extremely relaxing, too. 

When heading out, you’ll find Sanctuary is in a prime position for exploring the Theater District. It’s only half a block from Broadway. This means you get the best of both worlds – it’s relatively quiet, but very close to the action.

12) Bryant Park Hotel

The Bryant Park Hotel is found opposite the titular Bryant Park and is inside one of the most iconic buildings in the area.

This building – the American Radiator Building – was converted into the Bryant Park Hotel in 2001. As one of NYC’s earliest skyscrapers, it’s an art deco masterpiece that looms large against the Manhattan skyline.

13) The Muse New York

The Muse leans heavily into the Art Deco esthetic that defined the city in the 1920s. As a result, hot pinks abound throughout the hotel, lending it a distinctive look all of its own.

As a boutique, it’s smaller and more intimate than some of the other hotels in the area. This makes it good for those looking for something a little more personable.

The décor in the Muse’s rooms is playful and tongue-in-cheek. With pop-art throw cushions and cheeky graffiti found on the walls within closets, it’s certainly a unique experience.

14) Merrion Row Hotel And Public House

The Merrion Row Hotel and Public House seems transplanted from 19^th-century Dublin, with an unassuming air and simple cream-and-redbrick exterior. It certainly does not feel like the sort of hotel you’d find so close to Broadway.

Despite that, Merrion Row Hotel and Public House works wonderfully. It’s a much-needed slice of homespun hospitality in the Big Apple.

Delightful Irish touches are found throughout both the hotel proper and its attached public house. These include large paintings of the Emerald Isle and several portraits of famous Irishmen.

15) The Pearl

If you’re looking for a boutique luxury hotel, The Pearl is an all around solid choice. It doesn’t try to be snazzy or overstated, but instead prioritizes cleanliness and convenience.

One of the perks of staying at this hotel is the concierge. They will be only too happy to obtain Broadway tickets on your behalf. This makes attending a show on the world-famous street smooth and easy. And given how close the renowned Theater District is, it couldn’t get much easier.

Sharing is caring!